Benvenuto!

Welcome to Tiberio’s. Or maybe we should say, “Welcome back!”

The original Tiberio’s opened 30 years ago on Tallmadge Avenue in Lancaster. We then moved downtown onto Main Street where we served up the very best Italian for decades. When the traffic downtown slowed, Tiberio’s relocated to Ety Road on the north end of town. When the original owners decided to hang up their aprons in April of 2022, a group of local investors decided Tiberio’s needed to continue its legacy of serving the best pizza, pasta, and yes - strombolli in town. So those investors, including Bob & Maggie Bennett, Gary & Carey Smeck, and David Foraker, purchased Tiberio’s and moved it back downtown, to 416 N. Columbus Street. The new location opened its doors in March of 2023 and we are anxious to welcome customers, old and new, to our renovated, family-friendly space. Mangia, mangia!